Dubai Forums archive (old posts) - to navigate to the current version click Dubai Forums
Dubai Expat Help Dubai Chat Dubai Romance Dubai Auto BMW for sale in Dubai Dubai High Tech Dubai Guide Luxury Villas in Dubai Accommodation in Dubai Jobs in Dubai Available Professionals in Dubai Learn Arabic Philosophy Forum

Dubai Expat Forum - Philosophy and Religion Forums

The way forward....


GoodBai It is heartening how ordinary Muslims have been lining up to condemn people like Hamza who called for people to kill, poison and inflict pain in the name of God. Thankfully the overwhelming majority just want to lead normal, peaceful lives and reject the lunatics who preach hatred and revenge. Those non-extremist Muslims who came into contact with Hamza are appalled by what he preached and have publicly said so. This is what will win through in the end. Those fantasy world, apocalyptic soap-box crazies with their fire and brimstone and death and destruction (and yes there is at least one on here) are just a tiny minority and seem to revel in stirring the pot but most thankfully want no part of it. I have faith in normal, decent people, both Muslim and non-Muslim, and they are the ones who will triumph in the end NOT the voices of hatred. In the case of the cartoons I am astonished that some on here have said that burning down buildings and issuing threats is a reasonable response. Yes, these cartoons have caused offence to people whose religion governs major parts of their lives but the way to respond is to comdemn it, call for a retraction, seek the sacking of those who may have made a mistake in publishing and generally point out - in a reasonable and responsible way. - that is has genuinely caused offence. But to perpetrate violence and call for violence is way out of proportion despite the offence caused. And it's just paranoia to see this as part of some kind of global bid to destroy Islam. Perhaps some people know about the Life Of Brian film about the life of Christ by the Monty Python team many moons ago? Well, it caused deep offence to some Christians with its hilarious satire on religion and the story of Jesus. But I don't think people called for John Cleese and Co to be slain in the name of Christ and film studios to be razed to the ground. I believe they made their protests known, got their point across in a proper way and then got on with their lives..... PERHAPS IT'S TIME TO DO THE SAME.
arniegang I can remember people out the cinema's with placards etc asking people not to go in. They were very peaceful and dignified, and the same happened when the "Exorcist" was released. Liban This subject is now in overkill mode. People seem to have dug opinion "trenches" and locked themselves in them. Those who keep saying they don't understand Muslim anger by now perplexes many Muslims. Thread locked. sniper420 hahahahhaa it's one of those rare lovely moments to see Liban pissed! :lol: Andyba The thread is open. kanelli Rare? :lol: sniper420
Yep rare - so pissed that he will swallow basket full of red chillis and wet hsi pants (loose motion). arniegang
:lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: kelly1966 Very well done Andy...... castellano gudbai,,,, when you compare those film which is unsulting for christians with the carrecatures ,, you are just mixing the cards ,,, films about the christ are being made in christian countries , and its own majority ppl are christians , so if they choose to insult their own religion ,, then its up to them ,,, but to start aiming other religions , it is just not the same .
ok i agree that teh response shouldnt have been through violance ,, but our protest is not only about showing that we dont agree ,, its about that it hurts Muslims and something should have been done about it . still i dont say that violance is the key ,,, but also ,, its not our aim just to show our protest .
and by the way,, guys , although i dont agree with the way that Liban post his comments here ( i mean the agressive way he uses ) ,,, i dont see any problem with his comment here now
,, i mean his comment that you started a big thing about ,,, he is saying his own opinion ( speaking about freedom of speech ! ) and there is a point of view in what he said ,, ppl are still talking about the violance that happened ( despite all the violance from other regims ) just to distract the attention from the main subject which is the insult that has been brought on the Prophet pbuh .
so ,, hounestly i will tell my opinion here ,,, guys ,, do you enjoy the way that Liban starts being aggressive with you ? why do you need to comment on his comment in this way ??? dont you see that you are not being responssible for making him start something here now ? i mean i you dont like his way in posting , then you shouldnt urge him to do that . i dont mean that you should be affraid of him or whatever ,, but guys you made thread to speak about him . why do you need to start with him here now again ???? guys ,, being fair , really i wasnt commenting on what you have been posting about him coz simply he gave you a chance to show your side of aggression also , but now i can see another thing ,, that you are seeking for this kind environment here in the forum.
god bless .

1 Dubai Jobs .com The First Place to Find a Job in Dubai
kanelli Castellano, Liban closed a thread because he didn't like the poster and the contents. That is abuse of moderating powers. What you fail to note is that someone posted a thread also about the Danish cartoons on the same day and after Goodbai's thread - yet Liban was online and contributing to threads - and he did not close it. Why? Because he wasn't biased against the content or the poster, like he was in Goodbai's case. Liban's comments and actions on this forum get the responses they deserve. arniegang K please do not be racist or troll threads :wink: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: kanelli I'd like to address Liban's comments actually. I can understand the anger of Muslim people, just not its manifestation in actions like burning property, threatening to kill people, and actually killing people. It is only the radicals who are like this, of course, not the average moderate Muslims. I'm sure that they too don't understand violent words and violent actions of the extremists. Liban likes to speak for all Muslim people, when he really shouldn't - especially when his views are leaning towards or firmly in the radical side. kanelli
:lol: :wink: Chocoholic Castenello, I don't think it's mixing cards at all. It doesn't matter who does what to intentionally or not make insulting material. Goodbai's example of Monty Python is spot on, in fact should it not be found more offensive in the fact that it was made by people who may or may not be Christian in Christian countries making fun of it? The film was banned across the globe, up until 1999 it was still banned in some cities in the UK! But now people just take it as it was meant to be taken as a piece of slap-stick comedy and it's one of the highest grossing films ever constantly winning awards and accolades. It's tongue in cheek and that's how it was meant to be seen. What you're basically saying is that if a muslim in a muslim country drew a caricature of the Prophet than that would be OK? Plus you keep neglecting the fact that the Imams who took the drawings to the Middle East, many of which weren't even printed, are accountable for much of the outcry. Had they not thrust it under the nose of people you wouldn't even know about it. sniper420
Ah that shows u didnt do ur homework. I strongly disagree to ur last statement it happened in Sep 2005 and they tried their level best to meet with journalist and minister but they totally refused to meet with em. What was their next step? protest and spread the protest which was their right cos they had the right to protest. This was the reason why it took so long to materialize.
Take it this way- if somebody insults ur mom , u warn em and try to solve the issue by talk but it the person closes ears and refuses to obey what do u do? Sit there like a fool and bear the insult or call backup? Chocoholic I was posing a question to Castenallo, not you Sniper. And that's not what I read anyway. The cartoons were publish well before Sept 2005. Either way many of the ones the Imams had in their possession still weren't the ones printed, but much worse - so they're still responsible in part for inflaming things. sniper420
Ah no wonder u get ur info by reading tabloids ......radadada Chocoholic It's been published in all the press. You just don't read at all.
avkurian Hi all, I have been quite distressed by the response of the Muslims around the world. Good friends of mine who I have discussed this with feel that the publishing of these cartoons are especially offensive in light of recent events in the EU where people were punished for denying the holocaust. Publishing cartoons may have offended the Muslim world, but what a missed opportunity to respond in a mature and diplomatic manner! Burning flags and embassies, making death threats, and random violence- elements of the Islamic community seem to be working overtime to give the whole religion a bad name. I think one of the key reasons is that Muslims are not able to separate religion from state, even in their minds. This is why no one in the Muslim world understands that the Danish PM cannot apologise for the actions of one newspaper. Separation of religion and state is something that most countries have even fought hard to attain, and this should be even more popular in this part of the world. Simply put, caricaturing a religious figure is not really insulting the sentiments of a large number of nations! Something else I feel is, what makes Muslims think that their feelings especially looked after? If my God, His teachings, and representatives can be made fun of, why not yours? Coming to boycotting all the nations that have caricatured the Prophet (PBUH) and the allegation that the Imperial West and Zionist lobbies are working overtime to find ways to demean Islam, lets start with boycotting Egypt & Jordan, where papers have also published the cartoons. Here's to peace.. castellano



Dubai Forum | Paris Forum | Vegan Forum | Brisbane Forum | 3D Forum | Classified Jobs in Dubai | Listings of Jobs in London | London classified ads Portal
| © 2021 Dubai Forums | Privacy policy