Dubai Forums archive (old posts) - to navigate to the current version click Dubai Forums
Dubai Expat Help Dubai Chat Dubai Romance Dubai Auto Car insurance in Dubai Dubai High Tech Dubai Guide Dubai apartments for rent Accommodation in Dubai Jobs in Dubai Available Professionals in Dubai Learn Arabic Philosophy Forum

Dubai Expat Forum - Philosophy and Religion Forums

Some of the Miracles of the Holy Prophet Muhammad ( sallala


event horizon Taken from one of around 50,000 dawa websties off of google:
event horizon Here's my favorite and one recorded in the Koran (so we know beyond any doubt that the moon was physically split by Muhammad):
Splitting of the Moon
"The Hour has drawn near, and the moon has been cleft asunder" [Qur'an 54:1]
Volume 6, Book 60, Number 388:
Narrated Abdullah:
The moon was cleft asunder while we were in the company of the Prophet, and it became two parts. The Prophet said, Witness, witness (this miracle)."
Roadtester A moon splitting - eclipse maybe? Lost in transcription and translation I guess? Berrin Hey Roadtester Do you believe in God being as the ultimate creator and all powerfull? :wink: / Remember what the surah said…. The Initiator of the heavens and the earth: to have anything done, He simply says to it, "Be," and it is. Would you agree with me that we humans are given limited abilites to understand how he does it, or how we appear to see moon splitting through the eyes in that sense… Just like the babies develop in mothers womb and the way the soul enters into the body and stays there to give us life…(It happens but we don’t understand how it happens without human inteferance) May be you too shoud read the 99 names attributed to God in quran for wider perspective of his power. / shafique Taken from the Wiki entry for the splitting of the moon:

So apparently a King in India witnessed this event and converted to Islam.
Some suggest that the event may have been a natural event - such as a comet hitting the moon and sending out a plume of dust that made it appear that the moon had been split. I've read of some medieval monks witnessing such an event - but I think that report is contentious.
For me, the Islamic history records what the opponents of Islam said and did when the Quran was being revealed. The miracle of the splitting of the moon is in the Quran and there is no record, to my knowledge, of the Arabs of the time stating that this reported event never took place and using this as a point to reject the Quran as false. (They rejected the Prophet, pbuh, and the Quran for other reasons - just not this.)
The Quran actually says that those witnessing the miracle didn't all become Muslims straight away - but dismissed what they saw as 'just magic'.
I'll see if I can find a reference to medieval monks.
Cheers,
Shafique shafique Ah, trusty old Google.
Here's an article explaining how the moon can appear to be split into two - and be only visible to a limited number of people. (It's debunking a theory that the medieval account is describing a bigger impact, but states as to how the apparent splitting of the moon witnessed could have occured):

event horizon
So, this Indian King witnessed the moon split and converted to Islam?
Do you have any Western historians verifying such a tale by any chance? Or is this another story found on fifty million different dawah websites?

Cool - so we both agree that the Koran says Muhammad split the moon as a sign to the unbelievers (it's interesting to note that Muhammad was not able to perform other signs for the unbelievers and the Koran even records this).
It is also instructive to read an explanation of what the Arabic says (taken from an Arabic speaking Muslim):

So, the moon did not split on its own or appear to split due to a natural event - unless Allah created a comet just to strike the moon, that could be one explanation. But the Koranic passage says the moon was split, not that it was hit by a comet and appeared to split.
Surely Allah would have been able to distinguish the difference between the moon splitting and a comet striking it in any event. shafique The miracle of the splitting of the moon is in the Quran and also in Hadith. This is completely analagous with the miracles described in the Bible - such as the sun being stopped in its tracks to help help Joshua, or Jesus walking on water, Moses parting the Red Sea etc etc The reports of an Indian king seeing the astronomical event, and of later Christian Monks reporting seeing a similar event just lend weight to those who argue that this was a natural phenomenon that occured under God's guidance. What made it a miracle was that Muhammad, pbuh, prophecised it would happen and it happened (i.e. he pointed at the moon and it appeared to split, then it 'joined' up again - those with him saw it, the non-believers attributed the sight to magic). In the scheme of things - I think the Quranic account of the moon splitting is more credible than the Biblical account that God stopped the Sun for Joshua. (My personal view is that this Biblical account is metaphorical - or perhaps another example of an addition - but that's just me being logical again). Cheers, Shafique



Dubai Forum | Paris Forum | Vegan Forum | Brisbane Forum | 3D Forum | Classified Jobs in Dubai | Listings of Jobs in London | London classified ads Portal
| © 2021 Dubai Forums | Privacy policy